About 2 months ago I was at home, flipping through the channels and of course nothing was on so I ended up watching the food network. Normally I'm not a fan of Barefoot Contessa, but this recipe caught my eye since I'm always looking for a good steak recipe. I'm very picky about how my steak is cooked and I like it well done. When I'm at a restaurant people always say, "you're ruining the steak ordering it well done," and only on rare (pun intended) occasions does the steak come to the table with ZERO pink in the middle. My theory is chefs think I don't really want my steak cooked well done because I know nothing about steaks. I promise, I know what I like and I'm not one to hesitiate to send food back either, you just need to be polite about it.
I made this for a date night in on New Years Eve, it was PHENOMENAL, we couldn't stop talking about how tender and juicy the steak was. The cheese sauce you make with it, just adds something to it. I don't know if I'll be able to order another steak at a restaurant because now I can make one without it being tough or using a grill. You'll need to use a oven proof pan, I use the cast iron skillet and a couple strings of cooking twine.
 |
| This picture is from the first time I made the steaks, I omitted the extra seasoning because I think the salt, pepper, and garlic are enough. |
Adapted from
Barefoot Contessa
Ingredients
- 2 Filet Mignons
- 4 Tablespoons Unsalted Butter
- 2 Cloves of Garlic (Minced)
- Sea Salt
- Freshly Ground Pepper
- Olive Oil
Heat up cast iron skillet and preheat oven to 400 degrees. Pour sea salt and freshly ground pepper on a plate (you want enough to completely cover the steak). Cover steak with olive oil and dip each steak in the salt and pepper mixture making sure to cover completely. Tightly tie cooking twine around each steak. Once the skillet is hot, brown each side of the steak including the edges. Place 1 tablespoon of butter on top of each steak and sprinkle with minced garlic. Put the steak in the oven and bake until you get the desired amount of pink. Remember it will continue to cook once removed from the pan, so adjust time accordingly. For well done, cook for about 25 minutes, medium well about 20, minutes, medium about 15 minutes, medium rare about 10 minutes, and rare about 8 minutes. Once the steak is cooked to your liking, remove from the pan onto a plate. Put remaining pads of butter on the steaks and cover tightly with foil for 5 minutes. Pour
Blue Cheese Sauce on top.